Boy injured when his zip allegedly got caught in washing machine door settles for €25k

Four Courts

19 January 2023

It was claimed boy lost his balance and his right arm went inside the tub, which was in operation allegedly opened, and he suffered a double fracture, court heard

Jamie Luke Moran was nearly five years of age and was playing at home when it was claimed his zip got caught and the door of the family washing machine, which was in operation allegedly opened. The boy, it was claimed, lost his balance and his right arm went inside the tub and he suffered a double fracture.

The boy’s counsel, Conor Halpin SC instructed by Barra Newham solicitor, told the court it was “a bizarre case”. 

Jamie, he said, was “running and playing” with his seven-year old brother at the time. The boy was taken to hospital where he had to have surgery but has since made a full recovery.

The settlement against Electrolux Group Ireland Ltd is without an admission of liability and counsel said it represented just about half the full value of the case because of the difficulties in relation to liability.

Counsel said the settlement also includes a further €25,000 towards the boy’s legal costs.

Jamie Luke Moran, now aged 14, of Cushla Grove, Monksland, Athlone, Co Roscommon, had sued Electrolux Group Ireland Ltd, with registered offices at Westland Park, Nangor Road, Dublin over the incident in September 2013.

It was claimed that as a result of his clothing catching the washing machine door, the boy lost his balance and his arm allegedly became caught in the spinning motion of the machine.

It was further alleged his arm was severely twisted amongst the clothing and he was very shaken and upset . He was brought by ambulance to hospital where it was found he had a double fracture and a “floating elbow”. 

He had to have surgery and had to wear a cast for six weeks. He had a further procedure the following month but later made a full recovery.

It was claimed a washing machine which was allegedly defective had been provided.

Claims denied

Electrolux denied the claims and said it did not provide a washing machine which was defective or unsafe or constituted a hazard as alleged.

It also contended that any injury caused was not attributable to any wrong on the part of Electrolux, but arose by reason of the actions of a person unknown subsequent to the sale of the product.

Counsel told the court engineers who had examined the machine afterwards found the door in the locked position. He said they could not recreate the scenario and the machine was found to be in working order.

The washing machine was then sent for assessment in the UK. The Moran’s machine had been manufactured in early 2008 and bought by them in July of that year. The inspection report identified a plastic latch plate in the washing machine locking system which had a stamp from 2009.

Electrolux contended as a result there was no manufacturing defect. Counsel said the machine was still in warranty and it was “a complete puzzle”.   

Approving the settlement Ms Justice Carmel Stewart said the offer was reasonable considering the difficulties in the case and she wished the boy well.

Follow us for the latest updates & news

Recent News

Reform of Personal Injuries Procedures

The Personal Injuries Resolution Board Act 2022 was enacted on 13 December 2022 and awaits commencement. It reforms the PIAB process in a number of ways. The Act renames the Personal Injuries Assessment Board (PIAB), as the Personal Injuries Resolution Board (“Board”)...

Expert Reports: Who Refers?

Mr. Justice Twomey in the cases of Sarah Cahill v Brian Forristal and Rachel O'Riordan v Brian Forristal [2022] IEHC 705 has reiterated the High Court's view on the use of expert evidence in personal injury claims. Facts These two cases related to a rather minor...

Recent Articles

Analysis: Defending data breach claims in Ireland

Mason Hayes & Curran partner Colin Monaghan and associate Anthony Strogen look at recent case law developments concerning data breach claims and the threshold for awarding compensation.

The introduction of class actions in Ireland

The EU Representative Actions Directive (EU) 2020/1828 is to be transposed into Irish law by 25 December 2022, with effect from June 2023. The Directive aims to improve consumers’ access to justice by introducing a standardized EU wide legal mechanism by which...

GDPR – Data Across Borders

We love to travel, and so does our data – or rather, companies want to send our data around the world. A look on the international transfer of personal data and notes that new standard contractual clauses have increased due-diligence obligations on data exporters.

Join our Panel

You May Also Like...

Don`t copy text!